Medical Malpractice Cases

Dr. John A Manubay Medical Malpractice Cases

Court Case # CA093545

Indemnity Paid: $250,000.00

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number :M201263881
Claim Number :283919
Date Submitted :5/16/2012
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer NameCoverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE)Primary
Insurer FEINProfessional License Number
35-0506406 
Insurer Contact Information
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualSusan KSpielman
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
CityStateZip
Fort WayneIN46835
PhoneExtFaxE-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0340  reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualJohnAManubay
Insurer TypeStreet Address of Practice
Licensed14540 Cortez Blvd, Ste 123
CityStateZip CodeCounty
BrooksvilleFL34613Hernando
Policy NumberPer Claim Policy LimitsAggregate Policy Limits
631160$250,000$750,000
Profession or BusinessOther Profession or Business
Medical Doctor 
License NumberSpecialty Code & ClassificationCertification Number
ME75741Surgery - General 

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First NameMILast NameDate of Birth
    
Street AddressGenderCounty where Injury Occurred
 MHernando
CityStateZip Code
   
Location where injury occuredOther location where injury occured
Hospital Inpatient Facility 
Name of InstitutionCode
OAK HILL HOSPITAL100264
Location of Institutional InjuryOther Location of Institutional Injury
Operating Suite 
Date of OccurrenceDate Reported to Insurer
2/7/20074/20/2009
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Hernia
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
Surgical repair
Diagnostic Code : 
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
Improper treatment and delay in diagnosis
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
Hypoxic brain damage with amputations
Severity Of Injury
Permanent: Grave - Quadraplegia, severe brain damage, lifelong care or fatal prognosis.

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of SuitCircuit Court Case Number
11/16/2009CA093545
County Suit Filed inDate of Final Disposition
Hernando5/16/2012
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
Oak Hill Hospital
West Coast Surgical Associates PL
Palmer MD, Kevin
Piduru MD, Mallik A
Nature Coast Surgical Associates PA
Abuzarad MD, Husam
Physicians Partners Network PA
Bourghli MD, Mahmoud
Delta Health PA
Menendez MD, Francisco
Gil MD, Surrinder
Soliman MD, FawziM
Fawzi M Soliman MD PA dba Gulf Coast Surg Ctr
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
More than 90 days, after suit filed and prior to or during the course of mandatory settlement conference.
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court DecisionOther
No Court Proceedings. 
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
10/4/2011
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff?Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured$250,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel$27,229
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid$9,943
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss$0
Deductible$0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
 Incurred to DateAnticipated
Medical Expense$0$0
Wage Loss$0$0
Other Expenses$0$0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
N/A
 
Updates
 
No updates found.

 

 

This page is not displaying certain sensitive information.

Court Case # CA093545

Indemnity Paid: $250,000.00

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number :M201264435
Claim Number :5140577-03
Date Submitted :2/15/2013
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer NameCoverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE)Primary
Insurer FEINProfessional License Number
35-0506406 
Insurer Contact Information
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualSusan KSpielman
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
CityStateZip
Fort WayneIN46835
PhoneExtFaxE-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0340  reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualJohnAManubay
Insurer TypeStreet Address of Practice
Licensed14540 Cortez Blvd, Ste 123
CityStateZip CodeCounty
BrooksvilleFL34613Hernando
Policy NumberPer Claim Policy LimitsAggregate Policy Limits
631160$250,000$750,000
Profession or BusinessOther Profession or Business
Medical Doctor 
License NumberSpecialty Code & ClassificationCertification Number
ME75741Surgery - General 

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First NameMILast NameDate of Birth
    
Street AddressGenderCounty where Injury Occurred
 MHernando
CityStateZip Code
   
Location where injury occuredOther location where injury occured
Hospital Inpatient Facility 
Name of InstitutionCode
OAK HILL HOSPITAL100264
Location of Institutional InjuryOther Location of Institutional Injury
Operating Suite 
Date of OccurrenceDate Reported to Insurer
2/7/20074/20/2009
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Hernia
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
Surgical Repair
Diagnostic Code : 
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
Improper treatment and delay in diagnosis
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
Hypoxic brain damage with amputations
Severity Of Injury
Permanent: Major - Paraplegia, blindness, loss of two limbs, brain damage.

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of SuitCircuit Court Case Number
11/16/2009CA093545
County Suit Filed inDate of Final Disposition
Hernando7/18/2012
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
Piduru MD, Mallik A
Palmer MD, Kevin
West Coast Surgical Associates PL
Nature Coast Surgical Associates PA
Aabuzarad MD, Husam
HCA Health Services of Florida Inc dba Oak Hill Hospital
Physicians Partners Network PA
Bourghli MD, Mahmoud
Delta Health PA
Menendez MD, Francisco
Gil MD, Surrinder
Soliman MD, FawziM
Fawzi M Soliman MD PA dba Gulf Coast Surgery Ctr
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
More than 90 days, after suit filed and prior to or during the course of mandatory settlement conference.
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court DecisionOther
No Court Proceedings. 
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
10/4/2011
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff?Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured$250,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel$29,739
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid$11,869
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss$0
Deductible$0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
 Incurred to DateAnticipated
Medical Expense$0$0
Wage Loss$0$0
Other Expenses$0$0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
N/A
 
Updates
 
 
Date of Change:2/15/2013 1:12:03 PM
Reason for Change:Update ALE
 
Field ChangedFormer ValueNew Value
Amount of Loss Adjustment Expense Paid to Defense Counsel2948329739
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid1186811869

 

 

This page is not displaying certain sensitive information.

Court Case # 2017-CA-398

Indemnity Paid: $250,000.00

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number : M201885345
Claim Number : 1038473-01
Date Submitted : 8/28/2018
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer Name Coverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE) Primary
Insurer FEIN Professional License Number
35-0506406  
Insurer Contact Information
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual Lynn Louthan
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
City State Zip
Ft Wayne IN 46835
Phone Ext Fax E-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0778     reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual John A Manubay
Insurer Type Street Address of Practice
Licensed 11343 Cortez Blvd
City State Zip Code County
Brooksville FL 34613 Hernando
Policy Number Per Claim Policy Limits Aggregate Policy Limits
631160 $250,000 $750,000
Profession or Business Other Profession or Business
Medical Doctor  
License Number Specialty Code & Classification Certification Number
ME75741 Surgery - General  

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First Name MI Last Name Date of Birth
       
Street Address Gender County where Injury Occurred
  F Hernando
City State Zip Code
     
Location where injury occured Other location where injury occured
Physician's Office  
Name of Institution Code
   
Location of Institutional Injury Other Location of Institutional Injury
   
Date of Occurrence Date Reported to Insurer
5/23/2014 11/7/2016
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Intermittently painful and enlarging right breast mass with blood tinged nipple discharge
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
excisional biopsy on right breast mass, subcutaneous mastectomy without reconstruction of right breast
Diagnostic Code :  
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
negligent in the care and treatment of patient
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
benign pathology, infection, loss of breast tissue, disfiguration, and need for future surgery
Severity Of Injury
Permanent: Significant - Deafness, loss of limb, loss of eye, loss of one kidney or lung.

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of Suit Circuit Court Case Number
4/4/2017 2017-CA-398
County Suit Filed in Date of Final Disposition
Hernando 5/14/2018
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
 
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
More than 90 days, after suit filed and prior to or during the course of mandatory settlement conference.
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court Decision Other
No Court Proceedings.  
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
5/7/2018
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff? Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured $250,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel $44,477
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid $19,133
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss $110,000
Deductible $0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
  Incurred to Date Anticipated
Medical Expense $0 $0
Wage Loss $0 $0
Other Expenses $0 $0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
n/a
 
Updates
 
 
Date of Change: 8/28/2018 10:20:03 AM
Reason for Change: ALE UPDATE
 
Field Changed Former Value New Value
Amount of Loss Adjustment Expense Paid to Defense Counsel 43077 44477
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid 18296 19133

 

 

This page is not displaying certain sensitive information.

Court Case # 272017CA001123CAXMX

Indemnity Paid: $250,000.00

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number : M201887184
Claim Number : 1038006-01
Date Submitted : 12/4/2018
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer Name Coverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE) Primary
Insurer FEIN Professional License Number
35-0506406  
Insurer Contact Information
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual Lynn Louthan
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
City State Zip
Ft Wayne IN 46835
Phone Ext Fax E-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0778     reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual John A Manubay
Insurer Type Street Address of Practice
Licensed 11343 Cortez Blvd
City State Zip Code County
Brooksville FL 34613 Hernando
Policy Number Per Claim Policy Limits Aggregate Policy Limits
631160 $250,000 $750,000
Profession or Business Other Profession or Business
Medical Doctor  
License Number Specialty Code & Classification Certification Number
ME75741 Surgery - General  

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First Name MI Last Name Date of Birth
       
Street Address Gender County where Injury Occurred
  F Hernando
City State Zip Code
     
Location where injury occured Other location where injury occured
Hospital Inpatient Facility  
Name of Institution Code
SPRING HILL REGIONAL HOSPITAL 111525
Location of Institutional Injury Other Location of Institutional Injury
Operating Suite  
Date of Occurrence Date Reported to Insurer
5/8/2015 10/26/2016
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Right upper quadrant pain with nausea, admitted.
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
Surgical consultation, laparoscopic cholecystectomy
Diagnostic Code :  
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
Failing to recognize surgical error and treat injury in a timely manner
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
Gastric anatomy is permanently and radically altered, constant abdominal pain
Severity Of Injury
Permanent: Significant - Deafness, loss of limb, loss of eye, loss of one kidney or lung.

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of Suit Circuit Court Case Number
10/16/2017 272017CA001123CAXMX
County Suit Filed in Date of Final Disposition
Hernando 11/26/2018
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
Access Health Care Physicians LLC dba Access Health Care Phy
Hernando HMA LLC dba Bayfront Health-Spring Hill
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
More than 90 days, after suit filed and prior to or during the course of mandatory settlement conference.
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court Decision Other
No Court Proceedings.  
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
11/21/2018
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff? Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured $250,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel $28,064
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid $10,964
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss $250,000
Deductible $0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
  Incurred to Date Anticipated
Medical Expense $0 $0
Wage Loss $0 $0
Other Expenses $0 $0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
n/a
 
Updates
 
 
Date of Change: 12/4/2018 3:00:54 PM
Reason for Change: update the non-economic information
 
Field Changed Former Value New Value
Injured Person Total Non-Economic Loss 0 250000

 

Court Case # 2013-CA-998

Indemnity Paid: $150,000.00

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number :M201471532
Claim Number :1011533-01
Date Submitted :8/4/2014
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer NameCoverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE)Primary
Insurer FEINProfessional License Number
35-0506406 
Insurer Contact Information
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualSusanKSpielman
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
CityStateZip
Fort WayneIN46835
PhoneExtFaxE-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0340  reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
TypeFirst NameMILast Name
IndividualJohnAManubay
Insurer TypeStreet Address of Practice
Licensed11343 Cortez Blvd
CityStateZip CodeCounty
BrooksvilleFL34613Hernando
Policy NumberPer Claim Policy LimitsAggregate Policy Limits
631160$250,000$750,000
Profession or BusinessOther Profession or Business
Medical Doctor 
License NumberSpecialty Code & ClassificationCertification Number
ME75741Surgery - General 

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First NameMILast NameDate of Birth
    
Street AddressGenderCounty where Injury Occurred
 MHernando
CityStateZip Code
   
Location where injury occuredOther location where injury occured
Hospital Inpatient Facility 
Name of InstitutionCode
SPRING HILL REGIONAL HOSPITAL111525
Location of Institutional InjuryOther Location of Institutional Injury
Operating Suite 
Date of OccurrenceDate Reported to Insurer
5/23/20121/14/2013
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Abdominal pain
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
Colon resection
Diagnostic Code : 
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
Improper anticoagulation
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
Death
Severity Of Injury
Permanent: Death.

Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of SuitCircuit Court Case Number
4/29/20132013-CA-998
County Suit Filed inDate of Final Disposition
Hernando7/23/2014
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
Spring Hill Regional Hospital
Nature Coast Surgical Associates PA
Malhotra MD, Guarav
Malhotra MD, Poonam
Brooksville Walk In Clinic LLC
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
More than 90 days, after suit filed and prior to or during the course of mandatory settlement conference.
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court DecisionOther
No Court Proceedings. 
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
7/21/2014
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff?Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured$150,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel$30,534
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid$3,221
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss$75,000
Deductible$0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
 Incurred to DateAnticipated
Medical Expense$0$0
Wage Loss$0$0
Other Expenses$0$0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
N/A
 
Updates
 
No updates found.

 

 

This page is not displaying certain sensitive information.

Court Case #

Indemnity Paid: $25,000.00

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 
Department File Number : M201677928
Claim Number : 1020638-01
Date Submitted : 2/20/2017
 
Insurer Information
 
Insurer Name Coverage Type
MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY (THE) Primary
Insurer FEIN Professional License Number
35-0506406  
Insurer Contact Information
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual Lynn Louthan
Street Address
5814 Reed Road
City State Zip
Ft Wayne IN 46835
Phone Ext Fax E-Mail Address
(260) 486 - 0778     reportaclaim@medpro.com
 
Insured Information
 
Type First Name MI Last Name
Individual John A Manubay
Insurer Type Street Address of Practice
Licensed 11343 Cortez Blvd
City State Zip Code County
Brooksville FL 34613 Hernando
Policy Number Per Claim Policy Limits Aggregate Policy Limits
631160 $250,000 $750,000
Profession or Business Other Profession or Business
Medical Doctor  
License Number Specialty Code & Classification Certification Number
ME75741 Surgery - General  

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report


 
 
Injured Person Information
 
First Name MI Last Name Date of Birth
       
Street Address Gender County where Injury Occurred
  F Hernando
City State Zip Code
     
Location where injury occured Other location where injury occured
Hospital Inpatient Facility  
Name of Institution Code
OAK HILL HOSPITAL 100264
Location of Institutional Injury Other Location of Institutional Injury
Operating Suite  
Date of Occurrence Date Reported to Insurer
8/1/2014 8/11/2014
 
Diagnostic Information
 
Final Diagnosis For Which Treatment Was Sought Including Patient's Actual Condition
Colo-vesical fistula secondary to diverticulitis
Operation, Diagnostic, Or Treatment Procedure Rendered Causing The Injury
Resection of sigmoid colon and colostomy
Diagnostic Code :  
Misdiagnosis Made, If Any, Of Patient's Actual Condition
Improper performance of procedure
Principal Injury Giving Rise To The Claim
Retention of surgical towel resulting in hernia and additional surgery
Severity Of Injury
Temporary: Major - Burns, surgical material left, drug side effect, brain damage. Recovery delayed.

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Medical Malpractice Closed Claims Report

 

Legal Information
 
Date of Suit Circuit Court Case Number
  *NR
County Suit Filed in Date of Final Disposition
*NR 4/8/2016
Other Defendants Involved in this Claim
 
Stage of Legal System at which Settlement was Reached or Award Made
Within the pre-suit period as set forth in 766.106 (more than 90 days before suit is filed).
Final Method of Claim Disposition
Settled by parties
Court Decision Other
No Court Proceedings.  
Arbitration
Claim not subject to Arbitration.
Date of Payment
4/7/2016
 
Financial Information
 
Was there a settlement Resulting in payment to the Plaintiff? Yes
Indemnity Paid by Insurer on behalf of Insured $25,000
Loss Adjust Expense Paid to Defense Counsel $6,928
All Other Loss Adjustment Expense Paid $89
Injured Person's Total Non-Economic Loss $25,000
Deductible $0
Injured Person's Total Economic Loss
  Incurred to Date Anticipated
Medical Expense $0 $0
Wage Loss $0 $0
Other Expenses $0 $0
Safety Management Steps Taken by Insured to Make Similar Occurrence Less Likely
N/A
 
Updates
 
 
Date of Change: 8/11/2016 10:45:08 AM
Reason for Change: ALE UPDATED 8/11/2016
 
Field Changed Former Value New Value
Amount of Loss Adjustment Expense Paid to Defense Counsel 5474 6867
 
Date of Change: 2/20/2017 3:22:58 PM
Reason for Change: ALE UPDATE 2/20/2017
 
Field Changed Former Value New Value
Amount of Loss Adjustment Expense Paid to Defense Counsel 6867 6928

 

 

*NR: Prior to 04/28/1999 this field was not required in submitted claims.

This page is not displaying certain sensitive information.

Alachua Baker Bay Bradford Brevard Broward Calhoun Charlotte Citrus Clay Collier Columbia Dade Desoto Dixie Duval Escambia Flagler Franklin Gadsden Hamilton Hardee Hendry Hernando Highlands Hillsborough Indian River Jackson Lake Lee Leon Levy Madison Manatee Marion Martin Monroe Nassau Okaloosa Okeechobee Orange Osceola Out of state Palm Beach Pasco Pinellas Polk Putnam Santa Rosa Sarasota Seminole St. Johns St. Lucie Sumter Suwannee Taylor Volusia Walton